People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I recently had Villa Maria for the first time and I was not disappointed! Their meatballs, penne alla vodka and sausage and peppers were all amazing. The owner was super friendly, I will definitely be coming back! ”
“ Villa Maria has been our long time spot for pizza and food. They have the best meatballs, sausage and peppers and pasta dishes in town by far. The staff is second to none with an owner who takes pride in his work. A ”
“ I discovered this restaurant through the Too Good to Go app and thank God I did! This is some of the best Italian food I have ever had. Especially the chicken rolls. I have been there three times since and even ordered trays through them to cater my family dinner. ”
“ Picked up a pie with meatballs & it was excellent! The gentleman who answered the call on my order was friendly & courteous. This is the way a classic pizzeria should be. Was my first time at Villa Maria's but definitely won't be my last. Well worth making the trip from East Meadow! ”
“ Their pizza is delicious. It has a thin crispy crust, you know the kind that snaps when you fold it, with lots of gooey cheese. (OMG... YUM!!!!) Just thinking about it is making my mouth water... I have to go there again... lol. It's a pizza joint, so it's not fancy, but it has GREAT food! AND they have some great lunch specials too!!! ”
“ The best pizza in town and the food is incredible. Have been coming here for years! My family recently used villa Maria for catering we got so much complements about the food. The staff and the boss were helpful and nothing but professional. 10/10 ”
“ Mike awesome, 10/10 service and atmosphere. Even washes his hands before making the pie. For me that's huge and the cheese pie was amazing not floppy or soupy like alot of long island spots! ”
“ Catered food from Villa Maria on Sunday for my husband's party. The food was amazing. Got so many compliments. Brought the leftovers to work today and got even more compliments. The owner and staff are extremely friendly. Cannot wait to get another party catered from here again! Thank you guys for your great food and customer service, you don't see that around too often anymore. ”
Menu
Fried Calamari
Broccoli Or Fresh Spinach
Chicken Caprese Wrap
Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap
Extra Side Of Dressing
About
Villa Maria Pizzeria
Welcome to Villa Maria Pizzeria, a beloved gem nestled in the heart of Bethpage, New York. Located at 376 N Wantagh Ave, this local eatery stands as a beacon for those craving authentic Italian cuisine. From the moment you walk through the door, the warm and friendly atmosphere welcomes you, a sentiment echoed by patrons who appreciate the personal touch brought by the owner and staff.
As you delve into the menu, you're greeted by a treasure trove of mouthwatering options. The standout dishes, praised repeatedly by delighted customers, include the succulent meatballs and the rich, creamy penne alla vodka. Each plate showcases a dedication to flavor and quality that's hard to come by. And let's not forget the sausage and peppers—another favorite that brings a burst of savory delight with every bite.
A particularly charming aspect of Villa Maria is the sense of community that pervades the restaurant. Regulars like Kyle Stephens have made it their go-to spot for years, appreciating not only the stellar food but also the staff's unwavering commitment to excellence. Jillian Saltzman captures the heart of the experience, noting the friendly demeanor of the owner that makes every visit feel like coming home.
The thin, crispy crust of their pizza is another highlight that merits recognition. Karen F describes it perfectly, invoking the irresistible snap of a well-crafted slice enhanced by gooey cheese—pure pizza perfection! Whether you're dining in or picking up a pie, Villa Maria delivers an exceptional experience every time.
For those seeking a culinary journey, the chicken rolls come highly recommended, having enchanted patrons like Kyraleigh Zinnel, who discovered them through the Too Good to Go app. Each visit leaves you craving more, as this spot effortlessly combines the essence of Italian comfort food with a welcoming spirit.
Your culinary adventure awaits at Villa Maria Pizzeria, where tradition and quality meet in every dish. Don't miss out on the chance to savor some of the best Italian food around, and discover why so many have made this pizzeria a cherished part of their dining routine. Make sure to call ahead at +1 516-433-0877 for takeout or to learn more about their enticing lunch specials!
Book a table